The diplomatic stage is set in Abu Dhabi. Luxurious conference rooms, impeccably dressed officials, carefully arranged national flags and smiles polished to perfection. Everything looks like the beginning of a historic peace agreement. There is just one uncomfortable detail: the participants seem to disagree about what peace should actually look like. On November 10, 2026, delegations from Russia, Ukraine and the United States resumed direct negotiations under American mediation. The talks are scheduled to continue on November 11. Washington is searching for a diplomatic breakthrough. Moscow wants its security concerns addressed. Kyiv insists on sovereignty, meaningful security guarantees and an end to hostilities. European governments are determined not to be excluded from decisions affecting their continent. Everyone is talking about peace. Unfortunately, they appear to have arrived with different instruction manuals. And that raises the central question: could the negotiations become a diplomatic trap, or is Moscow participating for reasons that have little to do with an immediate settlement? The Fundamental Disagreement The most difficult issue is not simply whether the fighting should stop. It is what happens afterward. Russia has repeatedly argued that a ceasefire without clear political and security arrangements could leave the fundamental causes of the confrontation unresolved. Ukraine insists that any settlement must include credible guarantees against renewed aggression, while rejecting imposed territorial concessions. These positions create a serious sequencing problem. One side wants important conditions established before hostilities cease. The other fears that negotiating under continued military pressure could undermine its position. Imagine two neighbours arguing over a property boundary. One wants to agree on the exact location of the fence before ending the dispute. The other demands that the confrontation stop before any final measurements are taken. Then a mediator arrives and cheerfully suggests doing everything simultaneously. A charming idea. But when the parties cannot agree on where the boundary lies, even a measuring tape can become an instrument of confrontation. The same problem exists in international diplomacy. A ceasefire is a necessary step toward ending many wars. But without implementation mechanisms and mutual confidence, it cannot automatically deliver lasting peace. Trump's Search for a Grand Agreement President Donald Trump has once again placed American diplomacy at the centre of efforts to end the war. His representatives in Abu Dhabi are special envoy Steve Witkoff and presidential adviser Jared Kushner. Their ambitions extend beyond securing a temporary pause in fighting. American proposals have opened discussions about wider European security arrangements, potentially involving Russia and European nations. Kushner has reportedly explored mechanisms resembling the former NATO–Russia Council, which once offered a formal platform for dialogue between Moscow and the alliance. For Russia, this represents a potentially significant diplomatic opportunity. Moscow has long demanded that its concerns about NATO and European military arrangements receive serious consideration. For European governments, however, the proposal raises a different question. Could a negotiation intended to end the war in Ukraine become a process in which Europe's security institutions are redesigned under pressure? Suddenly, the peace talks resemble a very expensive renovation project. Trump wants a diplomatic triumph. Russia wants its security demands addressed. Ukraine wants enforceable protection. Europe wants control over decisions affecting its own future. The contractors have arrived, but nobody agrees on the architectural drawings. Europe's Concerns European governments have expressed concern about being sidelined in a process that could reshape the continent's security environment. Representatives from European countries and institutions held consultations with American and Ukrainian officials before the main negotiations. That distinction matters. European involvement in preparatory discussions does not automatically mean participation in the direct trilateral format involving Russia, Ukraine and the United States. Several European officials have insisted that existing institutions, including NATO, remain central to any future arrangement. They also argue that Ukraine's sovereignty and territorial integrity must be respected. From their perspective, negotiating a wider security settlement without these principles could reward the use of military force. Moscow sees the issue differently, arguing that Europe's existing security structure failed to account for Russian concerns. The result is a confrontation between two fundamentally different interpretations of the continent's security order. And neither side appears particularly enthusiastic about accepting the other's architectural masterpiece. The Long Shadow of Previous Agreements Another obstacle is the almost complete collapse of trust. Russian political discussions frequently invoke the Minsk agreements as a warning against ceasefires that fail to resolve deeper disagreements. Russian officials have argued that earlier diplomatic processes provided Ukraine with valuable time to strengthen its military position. Ukraine and its Western partners dispute Moscow's account and attribute the collapse of previous peace efforts to Russian actions. The historical interpretations differ sharply. But the underlying problem remains undeniable: every new agreement will be judged against the failures of earlier negotiations. Who monitors compliance? Who investigates violations? What happens if a ceasefire collapses? Which countries provide security guarantees, and how would those guarantees operate in practice? What prevents a future government from rejecting commitments made by its predecessor? Diplomatic documents can be signed in an afternoon. Building a durable international security system, unfortunately, requires considerably more than elegant stationery and ceremonial photographs. What Happened on the First Day? The first day of negotiations in Abu Dhabi lasted several hours. American and Ukrainian representatives described the discussions in constructive or positive terms. Humanitarian questions, prisoner exchanges, security arrangements and potential next steps were among the topics discussed. Yet no comprehensive peace agreement was announced. The territorial question remains especially difficult. Russia continues to demand concessions that Ukraine rejects. Kyiv, meanwhile, insists that any durable settlement must preserve its sovereignty and provide meaningful protection against future attacks. The talks also took place amid continuing military operations. That creates an extraordinary contradiction. Inside the conference rooms, diplomats discuss stability and de-escalation. Outside those rooms, the war continues to produce destruction, suffering and new political grievances. Each additional attack makes future confidence-building more difficult. A positive press statement is not the same thing as a political breakthrough. Three Possible Reasons Moscow Is Participating First: Demonstrating Willingness to Negotiate Participation allows Moscow to present itself as open to diplomacy. That message is directed not only at Washington and European capitals, but also at countries maintaining relations with Russia. Even if negotiations fail, Moscow can argue that it participated in the process and put forward its own proposals. This can have diplomatic value independent of any final agreement. Second: Changing the International Agenda A broader discussion about European security moves the conversation beyond the immediate territorial dispute. For Russia, this provides an opportunity to place longstanding demands on the international agenda. It may also expose differences between American and European approaches. Such differences do not necessarily mean the Western alliance is collapsing. But competing priorities can create room for diplomatic manoeuvring. Sometimes the easiest way to discover disagreements among political partners is simply to invite them to negotiate the details. Third: Seeking a Strategic Pause A third possibility is that Moscow may see potential value in reducing the military and economic costs of prolonged fighting. A pause could also be valuable to Ukraine, which continues to face enormous military, economic and humanitarian pressures. However, the suggestion that Russia entered these talks solely because it urgently needs a ceasefire remains speculative. The available evidence does not establish that motive. Serious analysis requires distinguishing between what governments publicly say, what outside observers infer and what has actually been demonstrated. Can Abu Dhabi Deliver Lasting Peace? The outcome may be less dramatic than the public expects. Negotiators could establish a mechanism for further talks without reaching a final political agreement. They might agree on humanitarian measures or prisoner exchanges. Or they might leave Abu Dhabi with little more than a commitment to continue discussions. Even limited results could matter. A humanitarian agreement can improve lives without resolving every territorial or security dispute. But the central diplomatic danger remains unchanged. A settlement that looks impressive at a press conference may prove fragile if the parties cannot agree on enforcement, monitoring and long-term guarantees. Trump has political reasons to seek a visible success. Moscow wants recognition of its security priorities. Kyiv wants a settlement that does not leave Ukraine vulnerable. European governments want to protect the security system on which their own defence depends. Those objectives overlap in some areas and clash in others. And that is why Abu Dhabi is about much more than a photograph of negotiators sitting around a table. Is Russia walking into a diplomatic trap, or is Moscow deliberately using the negotiations to advance a broader strategy? Perhaps the most unsettling possibility is that every delegation believes it understands the game better than its opponents. History suggests that such confidence can become dangerous. Especially when everyone is smiling for the cameras while quietly preparing for a completely different outcome.